Yesterday was “Professional Day” at New York Comic Con 2014. And yes, the quotes are to imply sarcasm. This year, NYCC opened Professional Day up to everyone. Which had both good and bad consequences. The good? There was more cosplay on Thursday this year. I had a lot of very fun interactions with other cosplayers yesterday. The show floor and artist alley were open all day. If you’re at the con to buy things and meet people, this was a definite plus. The bad? There were lots (and I mean LOTS) more people there. Obviously. But the biggest drawback for me was the lack of quality professional panels. Last year, there were tons of cool pro panels (I went to Women in Comics, Fandoms in the Library [about creating library programs], and Tween Fantasy Booktalk panels). This year, there were a couple of “comics in the classroom” panels and a We Need Diversity panel (more on that later). And then a bunch of weird ones, like how to open a comic shop. Then we had some “standard con panels”. But, since it was Thursday, they were maybe less exciting than they would have been had they been scheduled for one of the weekend days.
I went to Comic Con crossplaying Harley Quinn this year (that’s me, making faces at the Sad Batman statue). I dress up a lot: Halloween, Ren Faire, Library Programs, Just Because, and this was possibly one of the most fun cosplays I’ve done. My Hogwarts Wizard costume always gets fun attention, but there’s not a lot of character in it. My quasi-fantasy just-back-from-the-crusades knight character is a lot of fun to play with other actors. My Elizabethan noble is a good ensemble piece. But this Harley was fun just for me. For the first time, I had people stop me for pictures (normally this happens for me as part of a group or during a bit). I have to admit, I kind of loved the attention. But I also know Harley Quinn pretty well as a character. I used her “voice” (phrasing, inflection, some pronunciation) and her attitude for a lot of my interactions. I had some fun bits with a phenomenal Joker, an intoxicating Poison Ivy (that’s funny if you know your comics), and several other Harleys. I was a little disappointed with the Batmen I met. I made faces at them, or tried to tease them, and they just glared at me. Which, I guess, is a Batman-ish thing to do. But it’s not very interesting.
The panels I attended this year were a Game of Thrones Fan Forum with Kristian Nairn and Daniel Portman (Hodor and Podric Payne), Arthur Darvil Spotlight, and #WeNeedDiverse (Comic) Books. The GoT fan forum was much more fun than I expected. I like the show, and both of the characters represented are fun, but they’re not headliners and I was a little leery of a long fan Q&A (because a lot of people have really silly questions). Also, this kind of panel is tricky. They can’t talk about what’s to come (SPOILERS!), and most of the questions one might have about the story can be easily found online or in books. But I was impressed. The questions were mostly entertaining, and Kristian and Daniel were hilarious. And poor Daniel kept getting embarrassed. I have to admit, I have a bit of a man-crush on Daniel after the panel, he was really fun to watch.
Arthur Darvil’s panel was pretty much the same, but without wikia moderators on the panel to supplement the questioning. Which meant that this time we had a headliner (he’s Rory from Doctor Who, also in Broadchurch, he was in Once on Broadway, and will soon be in Treasure Island at the National Theatre), but a whole lot of silly fan questions. He was charming and witty, but his panel laughed the raw joy we saw from the GoT chaps. They were obviously having a really good time, while Arthur had obviously done this before and it was less exciting for him. He did have some hilarious moments, mostly at Karen Gillan’s expense.
The #WeNeedDiverse panel was disappointing. At last year’s Women in Comics panel, I got to listen to a panel full of women talk about how they got into comics, both as creators and fans; what their experience was like, again as creators and fans; and what they hoped to see from comics in the future, both in terms of representation in the pages and behind the scenes. The diversity panel was four people. Half men, half women, and three of them were white. It started with an overview of horrible racial stereotypes in comics, starting back in the 30’s. They discussed how that was addressed, but then over-corrected with the original introduction of characters like Luke Cage and John Stewart. There was an awkward and poorly-addressed mention of the “Women in Refrigerators” and Hawkeye Initiative phenomena. The introduction finished with a ridiculously short look at some of Marvel’s current efforts to diversify their dramatis personae. Then they kind of talked about why diversity is important. One of the panelists said something like “I’m a skinny white guy from the suburbs, I can find representation of me anywhere I look in comics. But I still think we need more diversity.” It was incredibly awkward.
Still, I spent the day with some fun colleagues and had a great time cosplaying Harley. I was dubious about even attending this year after having a less than stellar experience last year. But I think I’d be happy to attend next year, if the opportunity is there.